So who won? Weigel says it was
Joe:When John McCain picked Sarah Palin, what did he want? An instant star who'd blow up the electorate, peel off Hillary voters, and purloin the 'change' message from Obama.
On those terms there's no question that the Democrats won tonight. Biden spent the night attacking John McCain's record and building up (with detachable honesty) Obama's. Palin spent the night re-selling Sarah Palin.
Michelle Malkin, however,
disagrees:She was warm, fresh, funny, confident, energetic, personable, relentless, and on message. She roasted Obama’s flip-flops on the surge and tea-with-dictators declarations, dinged Biden’s bash-Bush rhetoric, challenged the blame-America defeatism of the Left, and exuded the sunny optimism that energized the base in the first place.
That may be fine for the base, but what about the rest of the country? Ben Smith probably has the most
realistic take:Palin passed a pass-fail test, though she flagged as the debate went on. Though she was chosen for her emotion connection, she was the drier of the two candidates. But if the central worry was that she'd be a drag on the ticket, she likely returned herself to the same status as Biden and every other running mate in memory: Not, ultimately, a major factor at the polls.
My own feeling is that this was the opposite of the first Presidential debate-here it was Palin who was the challenger going up against the person with experience and managed to hold her own. Both basically sounded the same themes as their would-be bosses, but then again, people aren't voting for the running mates. Still, both candidates' respective supporters were probably pleased either way.